One solution different results with dilatation solution

[ozdemirhasan35]

In the dilatation building, when I solve all the blocks together, the columns that do not give an error give a joint zone error when they are solved alone, shouldn't the results be the same? I saw that the periods are different in the modal analysis report.

 

[Ismail Hakki Besler]

in the dilated building, when I solve all the blocks together, the columns that do not give an error give a joint zone error when solved alone, shouldn't the results be the same? You can review the file

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

The results should be exactly the same. Examine the system you entered with dilatation, there may be a connection between the blocks The connections are shown in orange. The change of periods indicates this.

 

[Levent Özpak]

When I solve all the blocks together in the dilatation building, the columns that do not give an error give a joint zone error when solved individually, shouldn't the results be the same? In the modal analysis report, I saw that the periods are different, depending on this, the St value changes, etc. I wonder if this is due to the project? You can view the file from

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

link.

Hello, It is marked in the picture due to the difference in elevation between the 2nd and 3rd blocks in the project you added. where seen, the raft is connected to the main curtains. Model the dilatations in separate project files since there is a level difference between the blocks. Good work

 

[ozdemirhasan35]

When I solve all the blocks together in the dilatation building, the columns that do not give an error give a joint zone error when solved alone, shouldn't the results be the same? In the modal analysis report, I saw that the periods are different, depending on this, the St value changes, etc. I wonder if it is because of this. You can examine the project file from the link

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

.[/ quote] Hello, In the project you added, due to the elevation difference between the 2nd and 3rd blocks, the raft is attached to the basic curtains at the marked place in the picture. Model the dilatations in separate project files as there is a level difference between the blocks. Good work

If I lengthen those curtains, do I need to model them separately throughout the basement, should I solve them separately?