Not counting the insolvency???

[Reform Group]

Hello friends, I ran into a problem. In a project we have drawn, soil appears around it in official documents and architectural project processes. The building has gained one floor of elevation and must have curtains on three sides. The projects have been approved and the license has been issued. In the meantime, the contractor dug the remaining three sides of the land and cleaned the area around the basement. When he did this, he made me an offer to remove these curtains as unnecessary. I said I wouldn't do it before the retaining wall is built and the project is approved. So far everything seems normal. The thing that confused me was: An elderly engineer working at a building inspection firm said, "my friend, keep the curtains in place in the project (the panel that does not continue on the upper floors), but calculate them individually and note that if not necessary, it may not be done". In other words, let there be no renovation project, no retaining project, and let's keep it on track. What I'm wondering is, is there such an individual account method? Let's put curtains when we want, let's not when we don't... Also, when I removed the curtains, I designed them as a sub-basement, all values and sonata drawings change. I would be glad if you guide me with your ideas. Thank you from now.

 

[cakilomer]

If you have solved the system as a wall on 3 sides, regardless of whether you design it as a sub-basement, and you probably assumed it to be rigid in one direction, the center of rigidity and center of mass will change on that floor. Also, when the curtains that absorb the horizontal loads on that floor are removed, more load is placed on the columns and the basement floor will be the most sensitive floor. confirm without entering that way, I tried to answer as far as I understand

 

[Reform Group]

What I'm really wondering is, is there such a thing as an "individual" curtain that can be applied in place when necessary and not applied when not needed? As far as I know there isn't. Another engineer that makes me wonder if there is anything that confuses me.

 

[sereze]

If you keep a distance of 10 cm between the curtains and the columns and floors, the curtains will not affect the system. There is no need for a curtain in the project, but there is an extra problem in writing. The contractor does not have the right to lower the level of the already existing land by digging. Has to comply with the current project. Does the architect accept the revision, will he remove the reinforced concrete walls and replace them with bricks and lower the finished level?

 

[Reform Group]

If you put a distance of 10 cm between curtains and columns and floors, the curtains will not affect the system. There is an extra problem with writing that there is no need for curtains in the project. The contractor does not have the right to lower the level by digging the existing land anyway. Has to comply with the current project Does the architect accept the revision, will he replace the reinforced concrete walls with bricks and lower the finished level?

The architect naturally says that he will not change it, at the same time I say that I will not change it, but because of a busy building inspector, I can't speak to the guys. It made me wonder if there is such a thing, this is actually the whole point.