Insufficient raft flooring reinforcement

[unalmh]

Hello friends, I could not overcome the problem of insufficient raft flooring reinforcement, I tried all the recommendations in the forum, but I still get an error. Is there a design problem? It's not a very big building, actually it is a 130 m2-based structure. The ground values are not low either, but I couldn't solve the problem.. Note: I didn't increase the diameter of the reinforcement, it should stay 14 on purpose? If there is a missing or faulty design in the project, I will take your advice

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

 

[unver]

Hello My suggestions; --Separate the basement curtains from the columns and curtains by 2 cm, so that they are not adjacent. -- If you reduce the distance between your Q14 Raft reinforcements, which does not save, it saves. (If the additional reinforcements are in a very small section and will not prevent concrete from entering between them, this application can be done in order not to change the diameter of the reinforcement.) Ünver ÖZCAN

 

[unalmh]

Hi My Suggestions; --Separate the basement curtains from the columns and curtains by 2 cm so they are not adjacent, --Make the curtains as group curtains, --In the final calculation, finish the analysis by making the finite element widths 0.25 m. -- If you reduce the distance between your additional Q14 raft reinforcements by 8 cm, which does not save, it saves. ? --''In the final calculation, finish the analysis by making the finite element widths 0.25 m.'' how can I do this ?

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

I had the same problem in this project as well. The raft tile does not save.. I can't ampatch because it is adjacent to the layout ?

 

[Levent Özpak]

--why do we need to separate the basement curtains by 2 cm. ?

There is no need for this if an application will be made to connect the basement curtains to the columns in place.

--''In the last calculation, it is finite Finish the analysis by making the element widths 0.25 m.'' how can I do this

-Make the Perspective Window full display. -Click the Curtain command. Then click the Select All command. All Curtains will be selected. -Click the Object Properties command or Ctrl+E from the keyboard Press the keys together -Curtain Settings dialog/Static/Reinforced Concrete tab, change the finite element width.You can do the same operations in slab and raft.

https://we.tl/t-TooRk90FkN I had the same problem in this project, raft slab does not save .. I can't ampatta because it is adjacent order ?

Insufficient raft reinforcement in the project is due to additional reinforcements.The problem can be solved by selecting larger reinforcement diameters from the reinforcement selection dialog.Note: A 4/5 Apply R for Y direction does not need to be checked in the Analysis Settings/TBDY Options tab. -There is an incorrectly formed floor called D07 on the basement floor. A warning is given in the geometry control. You can delete this tile by following the steps below. Run the geometry command. -Select the line "Insufficient slab or faulty slab axis" in the dialog that opens. Click the "Select Entity" line. -Click the plan window with the left mouse button. Press the "Delete" key on the keyboard. Incorrectly defined tile will be deleted. Good work

 

[unalmh]

Thank you sir Levi. I want the basic reinforcement to be 14. How can I solve it without increasing the reinforcement .. I did what you said, it still does not provide..

 

[Levent Özpak]

thank you Sir Levent. I want the base reinforcement to be 14. How can I solve it without increasing the reinforcement .. I did what you said, it still doesn't work..

"Apply 4/5R" in the Analysis Settings dialog because it is not needed in your project Unchecked the option. Slab, curtain and raft finite element widths have been made 25 cm. The superstructure-basic interaction connection magnification factor has been adjusted to the default value of 0.5H. In the reinforcement selection dialog, 16 rebar diameter has been selected for the raft additions. Basically, the problem of insufficient reinforcement is resolved. The minimum spacing of additional reinforcement can be reduced so that it does not cause any problems in practice, and it can be examined whether the problem of inadequacy is solved with a reinforcement diameter of 14.

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

 

[unalmh]

LEVENT, THANK YOU SO MUCH.. CAN YOU SEND IT IN A LOWER VERSION, NOT IDECAD10.20? I HAVE NOT UPLOADED VERSION 10.20 MORE. WHEN I RECEIVE CURTAIN DETAILS IN A PROJECT, THE PROGRAM CLOSES. I CAN'T GET CURTAIN DETAILS.

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

 

[Emrah YILDIZ]

Hello, You created the denim curtains on the ground floor by giving a negative upper level, so the curtains are reverse modeled. Define these curtains by giving them an elevation in the basement or by writing -60 cm to the upper elevation of -280 cm to the ground floor. In addition, the curtains you describe and the upper levels of the continuous foundations are incompatible. Note: There is no need to select 4/5R in both directions in the 'Analysis Settings/TBDY 2018 Options' tab. If you are registered to the ideCAD portal, you can download version 10.20 from the download section and save your files as an old version if you wish.

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

Good work.