Insufficient Beam Reinforcement and Supporting Problem

G

ganymede

New Member
Hello to everyone. I am solving a project for the first time with version 8. There are some problems I am facing in my project. I would be glad if anyone with knowledge can help. * I get the error of insufficient reinforcement in the beams on the 2-2 axis. When I look, I cannot see curtains in the middle of the reinforced concrete configuration of these beams, which are supported by columns at the ends and curtains in the middle. It's like she doesn't see the curtain. Even though different reinforcement diameters are selected, it is flat and the assembly is 12. (Beams 41 and 43) * There are some beams where I get an Nmax error. What is interesting to me here is that the relevant beam does not give this error on the lower floors, but on the last floor. (Beams numbered K5-K9-K28. I would like to get your opinions on whether K5 and K6 are consoles. The program did not automatically accept consoles.
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
 
It's true, you made a bracing error on the beams. This is not only in the place you mentioned, but also in other beams. You are making a mistake in the beams you have attached to the curtains in the axis direction. Therefore, the beams perpendicular to it seem to be stuck in these beams. When connecting beams parallel to the axis of the curtains, you should connect them to the nearest end. If the beam is a continuous beam, the other beam should start at the other end of the curtain. There is such an error in the place you mentioned in your project, for example, there is an error in connecting the K46 and K47 beams. For example, in the K47 beam, you connected the beam from the red point to the red point as shown in the picture. However, the correct thing is to connect the pink dot to the pink dot. There are no beams on the curtain. This method was also like that in V7, it's not a case of V8. Make corrections and reanalyze. There will probably be changes in other bugs as well.
 
Thank you for your reply, Mr. Nedim. I fixed a few of them by doing it this way. I'll take your suggestion into consideration for others as well. However, in this case, when the beam section is not connected to the rear end, the beam is cut at that point and the slab edges are not straight. Doing this again, when more than one beam is attached to the same curtain end, the lines of the beams are also intertwined. That's why I did this. In V7, I was solving these problems by entering some curtain elements with the column command and giving the curtain dimensions.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top