In the 1st basement, S24 and S22 give a stapling error.

[bha]

Good evening, when I got a report in my attached project, ide Yapı was giving a punching error on s24 and s22 in the 1st basement. it seems, however, I still encounter the same error in the reports. Is the punching error indicated by the letter Z in the connection between the column and the base or is the error in the column and deck point? What should we do to resolve this situation? Could an error in design or modeling cause this?

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

Thank you.

 

[Levent Özpak]

Re: ABOUT PUNCHING SECURITY Hello, In your project, a stapling warning has been given in the columns S22-S24 due to the superstructure, not the foundation. Since the slab edge was attached to the column without connecting the beam, the program checked for stapling. Stapling control is made separately for the floor thickness, both with and without a tray. In the event that a tray is placed on the slab, we have included in our notes the case of checking the punching only according to the slab thickness. To solve the problem, the borders of the D23 balcony slab can be created as in the sample project.

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

Good work

 

[erbilsancaktar]

Re: ABOUT STAPLING SAFETY While we're on the subject, I want to ask, how can we tell if the stapling is on the deck or on the foundation?

 

[Levent Özpak]

Re: ABOUT PUNCHING SAFETY

While we're on the subject, I would like to ask, how can we tell if the stapling is on the deck or on the foundation?

Hello, The floor where the rafter-free raft foundation is If there is a letter (Z) next to the column name when the "Basic control" option is not selected in the dialog, the stapling problem is caused by the floor slab.