Curtain cut safety problem

[SonDurak]

HELLO THERE; DUE TO THE ELEVATOR PIT IN THE BASEMENT FLOOR THERE IS A CUTTING SAFETY PROBLEM ON THE BASEMENT CURTAINS. HOW DO YOU PROPOSE A SOLUTION? THANKS...

 

[atillaaydın]

After correcting the geometric errors in your project, analyze it again

 

[SonDurak]

Even though I fixed the Geometric Errors, the Interrupt Security Issue Is Not Resolved.

 

[HakanŞahin]

Hello, In my opinion, when we define the curtains in the elevator shaft site and make a raft underneath, and make a superstructure-basic interactive solution, we add the elements made under the elevator to the structure. However, the elevator pit is actually a gap opened in the raft. Therefore, it makes more sense to me to solve the raft with a cavity, look at the state of the structure and finalize the project in that way, and then make a constructive reinforcement (for example, as much as the reinforcement calculated on the raft) for the elevator shaft. good work

 

[sahinsukru]

HELLO, THERE IS A PROBLEM OF CUTTING SECURITY IN THE BASEMENT CURTAINS DUE TO THE ELEVATOR PIT IN THE BASEMENT FLOOR. HOW WOUL YOU PROPOSE? THANKS... THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS ON THE ENTRY, I RECOMMEND YOU TO GET SUPPORT FROM AN EXPERIENCED CIVIL ENGINEER IN THE PROJECT.

 

[SonDurak]

Hi, According to me, when we define curtains in the elevator shaft site and make a raft underneath, we add the elements made under the elevator to the structure, whereas the elevator pit is actually a gap opened on the raft. Therefore, it makes more sense to me to solve the raft with a cavity, look at the state of the building and finalize the project that way, and then make a constructive reinforcement for the elevator shaft (for example, as much as the reinforcement calculated on the raft). I mean, in practice, the elevator curtains (continuing throughout the building) will press the raft we defined under the pit, and it will go down to that level as elevation. I couldn't quite understand the modeling you said, I would be very happy if you could show it by applying it on the project. The final version is attached. Thank you.

 

[Ismail Hakki Besler]

Hi, In my opinion, when we define curtains at the elevator shaft site and make a superstructure-basic interactive solution by making a raft underneath, we add the elements made under the elevator to the structure. . However, the elevator pit is actually a gap opened in the raft. Therefore, it makes more sense to me to solve the raft with a cavity, look at the state of the structure and finalize the project in that way, and then make a constructive reinforcement (for example, as much as the reinforcement calculated on the raft) for the elevator shaft. good work

Mr. HAKAN; Do the elements made under the elevator work separately from the building? In other words, in practice, the elevator curtains (continuing throughout the building) will press the raft we defined under the pit, and it will go down to that level as elevation. As you mentioned, I deleted the elevator pit part, the final version of the project is attached. Thank you..

When you lower the elevator curtains, if you make the curtain thickness the minimum raft floor thickness, this model will be correct. Otherwise, it will not be possible to save these curtains from the shear force. Instead of modeling like this, it would be appropriate to leave the curtains at the upper level, go down the elevator pit at the thickness of the raft slab, and make a raft on the elevator floor at the same thickness of the raft slab. Or you can keep the raft straight without dealing with any pits and give the detail like this.

 

[YasinTezel]

Mr. HAKAN, Do the elements made under the elevator work separately from the building? In practice, the elevator curtains (continuing along the building) will press the raft we defined under the pit, and it will go down to that level as elevation. I couldn't understand it properly, I would appreciate it if you could show it by applying it on the project. As you mentioned, I deleted the elevator pit part now, the final version of the project is attached. Thank you..

Hello, I recommend you to analyze the raft foundation as a flat model and give the elevator pit detail separately. You can paste the block file I added into your project with the paste from file command in the Project menu, You can edit it according to the elevator shaft dimensions and equipment in your project.

 

[SonDurak]

Hello there; We revised the project in this way, taking into account your suggestions about the elevator pit. but we still could not solve the cutting problem on some curtains, the final version of the project is attached, I would be glad if you could help. (ground floor - 1st floor I deleted a floor due to the same file size, you can copy it before analysis.) Thanks...

 

[design_building]

HELLO, I WOULD LIKE TO ASK ANYTHING. CAN WE USE THE DETAILS THAT WE CREATED BY OUR OWN DETAILS IN THE DETAIL BLK EXTENSION FILE YOU TOLD HERE. IF POSSIBLE, HOW CAN WE DO THIS? THANKS IN NOW

 

[HakanŞahin]

HELLO I WANT TO ASK SOMETHING YOU POST HERE IN THE FILE WITH THE DETAIL BLK EXTENSION FILE WE CREATED OUR OWN DETAILS. CAN WE USE THE DETAILS FOR THE LETTERHEAD? Yes, WE CAN USE THE program. There is the "Annotations" folder under the "Annotations" folder. Here are the title blocks used by the program. Files with the "txt" extension in the same folder are the title group placed on the drawings. You can put the "blk" extension files that you created in this folder and create your own title group with the txt file or edit the existing ones.

 

[design_building]

I have one last question, how do we turn a dwg file into a blk extension. I converted the bak file to blk but it didn't work.

 

[HakanŞahin]

I have one more question, how do we convert a dwg file to blk extension. I converted the bak file to blk extension but it didn't work.

Hello, import the dwg file into the program. Write the drawing you want to the file with the "block to file" command. This file is the block file ideCAD uses and its extension is blk. Similarly, you can open ideCAD's blk files with the "paste from file" command. Have a good work.

 

[projesoruları]

hi, i could not open this blk file, can you help me?

 

[baran21]

HELLO; DUE TO THE ELEVATOR PIT IN THE BASEMENT FLOOR THERE IS A CUTTING SAFETY PROBLEM ON THE BASEMENT CURTAINS. HOW DO YOU PROPOSE A SOLUTION? THANKS...

I HAVE REVIEWED YOUR PROJECT, THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS IN THE SYSTEM INSTALLATION AND DATA ENTRY BEFORE COME TO THE ELEVATOR PIT IN THE BASEMENT FLOOR. I RECOMMEND THAT YOU GET SUPPORT FROM AN EXPERIENCED CIVIL ENGINEER IN THE PROJECT.

Look, Mr. Şahin has stated some things here, if there is a data problem, you must first solve your problem.