Computer equipment and Static Analysis and Reinforced Concrete

[engineer_yildiz]

Dear Idecad family, Does the computer hardware difference affect the calculations (static analysis and reinforced concrete) of the Idecad program in the same Idecad installations? He states that when the projects submitted for control are reopened or analyzed on the computer of the controlling authority, the user detects errors/warnings on our computer while there is no problem on his own computer. Could this be due to hardware differences? If my question is not clear, I can expand it further if necessary. I wish you good work

 

[HakanŞahin]

Re: Computer hardware and Static Analysis and Reinforced Concrete

Dear Idecad family, In the same Idecad installations, does the difference in computer hardware affect the calculations (static analysis and reinforced concrete) of the Idecad program? He states that when the projects submitted for control are reopened or analyzed on the computer of the controlling authority, the user detected errors/warnings on our computer while there was no problem on his own computer. Could this be caused by hardware differences?

Hardware differences do not affect the static analysis and reinforced concrete results of the program. Same It gives the same result no matter which computer the project data is decoded in. Reinforcement and size changes, stirrup spacing, stirrup diameter, etc. changes made in the reinforced concrete dialog may affect the earthquake code controls in the next analysis, as the subsequent reinforcement fixation will affect the element bearing/shearing capacities. can change bee warnings. For a definitive answer, it is necessary to examine the project that is thought to be free of errors. Did you re-analyze the project that gave a warning/error when the analysis was performed on the project's computer?

 

[NYILMAZ]

If there is a version difference, of course, the results may vary. As is known, lower version projects can be opened with the upper version program. If the lower version project went to the control authority and opened it with the upper version program, it is normal for changes to occur.

 

[engineer_yildiz]

Re: Computer hardware and Statil Analysis and Reinforced Concrete

Dear Idecad family, In the same İdecad installations, Computer hardware difference is the calculation of the Idecad program. (static analysis and reinforced concrete)? He states that when the projects submitted for control are reopened or analyzed on the computer of the controlling authority, the user detects errors/warnings on our computer while there is no problem on his own computer. Could this be due to hardware differences?

Hardware differences do not affect the static analysis and reinforced concrete results of the program. The same project data gives the same result no matter which computer it is decoded. Reinforcement and size changes made in the reinforced concrete dialog, stirrup spacing, stirrup diameter etc. changes, subsequent reinforcement fixation will affect the element bearing/shear capacities and may affect the earthquake code controls in the next analysis. This can change the warnings of critical elements. For a definitive answer, it is necessary to examine the project that is thought to be free of errors. Did you have the project re-analyzed on the project's computer, which gave a warning/error when you analyzed it?

They make a solution on the desktop computer with high hardware and bring the program data. We haven't had a chance to backtest as you mentioned. But they say it's okay when they solve it on their own computer again. If the same situation happens again, I can send you the data. Thank you and Mr. NYılmaz for your information.