Column stapling error

[yasarusta]

good day, in my attached project, although the columns named 1-ground floor s23 and s25 continue at the top and bottom, I am getting a stapling error. 2- When I do ladder analysis, the graph appears below, I don't know if I made a mistake about bracing. 3-D17 flooring has to be like that for architectural reasons, I couldn't find an alternative shape for the beams I put in front of it, I would appreciate it if you have any comments on this subject.

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

 

[unver]

Hi Suggestion project attached -- If you are going to solve it together with the ladder, you should solve the semi-rigid diaphragm. (not exactly correct in stair bracing) --There is no need to solve with ladder in rigid solution, you must enter additional ladder loads as soon as the loads are taken. --Fix bugs in geometry control. Unver ÖZCAN

 

[yasarusta]

thank you for your effort, but the ground floor would be at the -40 level on the right of the raft floors as per the architectural project. stapling seems to have saved when I reset it. When I entered -40 again, errors occurred again.

 

[unver]

Hello

on the right, it would be at -40 level due to the architectural project. When I reset it, stapling seems to be saved. When I entered -40 again, errors occurred.

This foundation is 80 cm at -40 elevation, S25 column is 50/35 If you do it, there will be no problem. I would expect you to ask about the raft I lifted under the actual elevator. I suggest you to design the raft foundation under the elevator as in the link below. HOW TO MODEL THE ELEVATOR WELL

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.

 

[yasarusta]

Even if we do 80cm raft, column 50/40, it does not save, but does it make sense that it gives a punching error in the column that overlaps the column? the ground floor s25 column has no connection with the raft, it gives an error on it too

 

[Levent Özpak]

80cm raft, column does not save even if we do 50/40, but does it make sense that it gives a punching error on the column overlapping the column. The ground floor s25 column does not have a connection with the raft, it gives an error on it too

Hello , There is a raft foundation on the ground floor due to the level in the project.Punching control is normal as the S23 and S25 columns are connected to the raft foundation on the ground floor.Good work.