Beam purchase and shear safety problem

H

huseyinakkus56

New Member
Hello.. I couldn't solve the attached project no matter what I did.. Could you explain how the errors in the report and "shear safety is not provided at the column-beam junction" problems were resolved, or could you solve them and send the file again? File Link:
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
 
Hello My suggestions; --Make concrete C30 --Place beam on D12 slab end for stair bracing --Get stair loads --Fix (B) errors Corrected project is attached Ünver ÖZCAN
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
 
Thank you very much for your attention, but I cannot open the file because I am using an old version. Can you send it as ide8 (in old version)? (B) What do you mean by edit your mistakes? One of the main problems I have is to fix the (B) error; how can i fix it?
 
This is my suggested solution. I fixed geometry errors. You used two different concrete classes. I do not recommend. Separate in columns and other elements separately. It is not easy or possible in practice. Moreover, the curtain and the column were also different. Furthermore, you have made the rib flooring thicknesses of 15 cm. I think this is high. Many engineers use 7cm but I generally use 10cm. Concrete class saves the system with the whole c25. I made two columns square columns. In this way, it seems that there is not much trouble in architecture. By doing this, the B (column beam connection shear safety) error in those two columns has been resolved. Only error B remained in the polygon column. By making the arm lengths of the polygon column 175 cm, you can turn it into a curtain, so you can get rid of the B error there. But I didn't do it to save time.
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
N. YILMAZ
 
Hello.. I'm sorry, I'm opening the topic again, but I couldn't open the links you sent yesterday and "there are columns in the column-beam junction area that cannot be cut-safe". I need to fix this issue without changing the column sizes. I am in a very difficult situation and I need to get the report of this project very urgently. Can you please fix this problem according to the final version of the project from the link? (I'm using 8 versions, can you send it accordingly)
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top