Beam cutting safety and reinforcement not enough error

B

bakil

New Member
Shear safety is not provided in the k34 beam on the 1st floor and the reinforcement is not enough error, but when I copy the ground floor to the 1st floor, the error is corrected. My question is, no matter what I do to the k34 beam on the 1st floor, it is not fixed, why does it get fixed when I copy the floor, where do I make the mistake
 
Yes, I did and the problem was fixed and I tried another method, deleted the dirt, analyzed it again, and it was fixed again. There is no geometric error. Except for these applications, I made the beam size 30/70 in the project, it did not improve again. I wonder if it is a problem caused by idecad, I could not find the reason why. I couldn't upload because the project is 4 MB
 
Hello. In the project you uploaded as unfixed, there is DS (reinforcement fixing) on the 1st floor on the beams, with the error messages it gives when they are removed and the calculation is made; The error messages are the same when the ground floor is copied to the 1st floor and the calculation is made. So there is no error in ideCAD. You probably made different corrections in the project you uploaded because it was fixed. Note: --Do not fix the reinforcement in the new project, --There is almost no connection to the floor on the P2 curtain, --It would be better if you connected P2 and S10, --I suggest you model the ladder carefully, --There is DS in the raft, and increase the diameter. Unver ÖZCAN
 
Mr. Unver, I did what you said, it didn't improve. This time, the project gave a cutting problem in the k34 beam of the 2nd floor, but there is no reinforcement in any beam on the 2nd floor, what do you think is the cause? You can try it if you want. I will be glad if you can help. I followed the architecture in the staircase modeling. I could not connect the column and the curtain because of the stairs.
 
"bakil":4lo79omt" said:
In the k34 beam on the 1st floor, shear safety is not provided and the reinforcement is not enough, but when I copy the ground floor to the 1st floor, the error is corrected. I wonder what I do to the k34 beam on the 1st floor, why does it get fixed when I copy the floor? I'm doing
Click to expand...
"bakil":4lo79omt" said:
Unver, I did what you said, it didn't improve. This time, the project gave a cutting problem in the k34 beam of the 2nd floor, but there is no reinforcement in fixing the reinforcement in any beam on the 2nd floor. You can try it if you want. I will be glad if you can help. I complied with the architecture in the staircase modelling. I couldn't connect the column and the curtain because of the stairs
Click to expand...
Hello, The G value of the ground floor is different from the 1st and 2nd floors in the Germencikdozelenler.ide85 project. When the ground floor is copied to the upper floors, the G values on the upper floor and, accordingly, the analysis results will change. -The problem in the K34 beam is insufficient stirrups. In the Beam Reinforced Concrete dialog, uncheck the DS column. Analyze by selecting the reinforcement diameter of 10 for the beam stirrup from the reinforcement selection dialog. Some observations; -4. There are floor edges under the S10 and S8 columns on the floor. K1 beam is not connected to S08. In order to connect the sloping slab named D14 to the S10 column, define a beam compatible with the slab slope between columns S8-S10. Increase the beam height so that it connects to the K1 beam. Good work
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top